The same promenade may feel quite different when you hear birds among the trees, a splashing fountain or continuous traffic on a nearby road. We often describe a running environment through its appearance, yet sounds are also part of what surrounds us. They are more than background: they may signal what is happening nearby, evoke a personal memory or simply feel pleasant.
Human experiments with natural sounds provide interesting but varied results. A sound considered pleasant, a change in skin conductance and heart-rate variability are not the same measurement. Some studies found differences, while others did not. The useful question for runners is how to understand these data while retaining the roles of the real environment, personal preference and the attention needed to move through it.
A soundscape is an experienced situation, rather than the sum of separate sounds
The word soundscape directs attention towards human experience of the acoustic environment. We ask not only which sound sources are present, but also in what situation a person hears them. A fountain’s sound may be part of the same park experience as the space’s openness and the company. At another time, nearby traffic may come to the foreground. Labels such as natural and artificial can help organise sources, but do not replace a description of the whole encounter.
An original 2017 study compared sound experiences in three Copenhagen public spaces using on-site and laboratory appraisals. Researchers asked separately about loudness, acceptability, comfort and stressfulness. In the laboratory, measured sound levels predicted several appraisals better than they did in the actual on-site environment. The original human study offers an important lesson: listening to a recording does not always recreate a place’s full experience.
This is easy to imagine while running. Your movement, the purpose of your journey and the route’s other elements accompany the sound. In an example of our own, the same distant conversation might be pleasant social background in a square, but in another situation divert attention from a sign you are looking for. This is not a research claim about two specific effects. It illustrates why a sound file’s label is insufficient to predict personal experience.
Sound level and perceived pleasantness are separate questions
A measured sound level is physical data; judging pleasantness is a human appraisal. The two may be related, yet are not interchangeable. In the Copenhagen field study, comfort, acceptability and stressfulness did not always change together either. Water, wind, birds and certain social sounds received more favourable appraisals, but the on-site context mattered too. An environment can therefore be acceptable in one respect without every other appraisal being the same.
Instead of saying ‘quieter is automatically better’, name the question you are discussing. A splash considered pleasant and a disturbing, barely audible repeated rustle may receive different personal appraisals. This does not mean physical sound level is irrelevant or every pleasant sound is suitable without limits. The distinction simply clarifies that an instrument’s reading alone does not reveal every experiential variable.
The adjective natural is not a single quality stamp either. Water, birdsong, wind and moving leaves can represent very different stimuli. If research uses a mixture of these, its result does not automatically apply to every separate element. Behind the phrase ‘pleasant natural sound’, always look for exactly what was played, what it was compared with and what listeners were asked. Here, the method itself is an interesting part of the story.
Enlarge imageWhat did the laboratory experiment with birdsong and water show?
In 2010, Alvarsson and colleagues compared a mixture of natural sounds with different noise conditions in forty participants after a demanding mental-arithmetic task. The natural recording featured birdsong and a fountain. Researchers measured skin conductance and high-frequency heart-rate variability. Some comparisons of skin-conductance response were more favourable under the natural condition, particularly compared with loud traffic noise. They found no consistent condition effect in the HRV indicator. The original study reports detailed results that are not a single calmness response appearing in every indicator.
The researchers also varied the sound levels of the noise conditions. Not every pairwise difference between natural sound and quieter noises was significant. Retain this alongside the more favourable result. The study involved a targeted listening situation, rather than measurement during movement. It does not prescribe a sound level for runners, and the laboratory recordings’ duration does not establish a personal stress-management dose.
Skin conductance and HRV may appear together in research because they can provide different physiological information. One measurement’s result need not be erased by the absence of a result in the other, but a more favourable detail does not allow us to claim that every system examined changed. A precise sentence identifies the indicator to which the difference applies. If news retains only ‘proven to calm you’, it loses the detail needed to assess the evidence.
When birdsong provided no separate advantage
In 2019, Hedblom and colleagues compared birdsong, traffic noise and their mixture in 117 participants alongside the view of a virtual park. They followed recovery through skin conductance after an experimental stress situation. They found no significant difference in stress recovery between the sound conditions. The original human experiment is therefore an important addition alongside more positive sound research. The shared park experience, design and characteristics of the sounds all form part of the interpretation question.
A null result does not mean nobody can enjoy birdsong. It means that this design, participant group and endpoint did not show a sufficiently certain difference between conditions. ‘I liked it’ and ‘skin-conductance recovery differed’ are different claims. A sound experience can therefore be valuable to someone even when a particular physiological experiment does not find the expected group difference.
Equally, one positive result does not make other studies unnecessary. The kinds of sounds, their mixture, the demanding task and the measurement all influence which question is tested. A popular recording does not become a reliable calmness switch because a different, only partly similar recording appeared in research. The lesson is rather to examine the acoustic environment from several sides, also describing differing results.
| Concept | What do we ask? | What does not automatically follow? |
|---|---|---|
| Sound level | How large is the measured physical sound exposure? | The sound is equally pleasant for everyone |
| Preference | How much does the person like the sound? | Every physiological indicator changes more favourably |
| Skin conductance | What happened to the experiment’s particular activation indicator? | We know the whole experience of wellbeing or thought |
| HRV | How did the specified heartbeat-interval indicator change? | Skin conductance showed the same result too |
Birdsong can also carry personal meaning
In 2013, Ratcliffe and colleagues examined the perceived restorative quality of bird sounds through interviews with twenty adults. Accounts included emotional appraisals, associations in thought and relationships with nature. Not every bird sound was judged equally helpful. The original qualitative research shows what meanings people may identify. It does not establish the same thing as a randomised experiment analysing a physiological endpoint.
You can imagine a personal association through an example of your own too. A sound might evoke a holiday or a familiar morning route. For someone else, the same sound carries no such story. The example does not prescribe how you should feel or assert a mechanism present in everyone. It gives language for discussing meaning alongside acoustic characteristics. A pleasant environment may consist of experienced relationships as well as a list of sources.
The research presented should therefore not become a universal calming ranking of species or recordings. An interview can reveal what people say about their experience; an experiment can examine what happens under specified conditions. Your favourite sound can be a personal choice. You need not justify it by claiming it provably produces the same bodily response in everyone, nor be disappointed if someone else finds something different pleasant.
While running, sound is also information
A route’s sounds deserve interpretation beyond their restorative quality. They can reveal other road users, an approaching vehicle or a currently busier promenade. Your attention must also retain the information needed to move safely. Curiosity about natural sounds is not a task to exclude every other signal. A pleasant sound and an important traffic cue can be present simultaneously in a real environment.
Laboratory listening through headphones should therefore not be turned unchanged into a public-space running practice. This article does not recommend a volume that masks traffic or prescribe a recording for the route. If you want to observe a detail calmly, you can also do so at a safe stopping place without obstructing others. This is simple environmental attentiveness, rather than a compulsory stress-recovery exercise or a home replication of the research.
Sounds can feature in your own route description: where did you hear water, where did traffic become stronger, and which section felt pleasant to you? The answer is neither a noise map nor a health measurement. It is a detail that makes personal use of a place more precise. You need not turn it into a daily task or self-assessment system; noticing once that a landscape is more than what you see may be enough.
Enlarge imageNatural sound can bring pleasure without being a reliable state switch
The studies presented approached the question from different sides. They included controlled listening, a virtual park, on-site appraisals and personal interviews. Differing results build a richer conceptual picture, rather than a single simple recipe. We can distinguish physical sound, experience, a physiological indicator and the sound’s role in an environment. This says far more than ‘birdsong always calms you’.
If, as a runner, you enjoy the sounds of a leafy promenade or water, you can describe the experience in its own right. If you sometimes prefer other sounds, or an occasion brings no calm, that is not a personal failure either. A soundscape is an encounter between place and person, which can be studied and enjoyed using different tools. Precise scientific background helps you avoid having to add an exaggerated biological promise to your own enjoyment.
Sources
- Alvarsson and colleagues, 2010: recovery after natural sound and environmental noise
- Hedblom and colleagues, 2019: a null-result experiment on birdsong and stress recovery
- Ratcliffe and colleagues, 2013: meanings of bird sounds in interviews with twenty adults
- On-site and Laboratory Evaluations of Soundscape Quality in Recreational Urban Spaces, 2017
How Futószív articles are prepared: our editorial guidelines.


