Seventy per cent less aerodynamic drag: a figure that large can make running sound almost effortless. But a fluid-mechanics result concerns one part of the forces involved. To establish a reduction in the body’s total energy expenditure, we would need to know that component’s original contribution and the assumed connection between the mechanical task and metabolism.
This is not nitpicking. One study can report a large drag reduction and a much smaller estimated economy benefit in complete agreement. An original hundred-unit energy budget, precise units and results from two real models help trace what happens to the large percentage. The examples teach calculations; they do not predict personal performance.
First identify what is being reduced by seventy per cent
Aerodynamic force can be expressed in newtons. A reduction means the body experiences a smaller aerodynamic effect opposing progress under defined flow conditions. This differs from the body’s energy expenditure per unit time, expressed in watts, for example. The measures can be connected, but their percentages have different denominators.
In our mechanical example, a solo body experiences ten newtons of drag and three in a sheltered position. The difference is seven newtons, a seventy per cent reduction. If it moves at the same ground-relative speed under otherwise identical conditions, the associated external mechanical power is also seventy per cent lower. Neither the entire mechanical task of movement nor the body’s total expenditure has therefore fallen by seventy per cent.
The identical-conditions requirement matters. If the runner accelerates or the ground or wind direction changes, a new task is being compared with the previous one. First relate a drafting result to the same speed and a clear control. That separates what the formation changed from what a new pace demands.
Only one defined part of the hundred units is affected
Consider a purely illustrative energy budget. The total cost is one hundred units, five assigned to moving against air and ninety-five to all other tasks. Suppose the first part falls by seventy per cent while the rest stays unchanged. Five becomes one and a half, leaving a total of ninety-six and a half. The overall benefit is three and a half per cent while one component improves by seventy per cent.
The short formula in this simple division is: total saving = affected share × reduction within that share. Multiply five per cent as 0.05 by seventy per cent as 0.70 to obtain 0.035, or three and a half per cent. This assumes the affected share is appropriately defined within the same total budget. A mechanical share cannot be substituted into a metabolic denominator without explanation.
The same original exercise can use another assumed share. If the affected cost is two per cent, a seventy per cent reduction gives a 1.4 per cent overall benefit; with a ten per cent share, it gives seven per cent. These are not measured values for different runner types, but three possible inputs to the same multiplication. They show why the original share must accompany an impressive percentage.
Enlarge imageWhat do actual formation models show?
In Schickhofer and Hanson’s 2021 CFD study, a female body model was analysed at several speeds and arrangements. In the most favourable formation examined, the main runner’s drag fell by 75.6 per cent, while the additional model estimated at most a 3.5 per cent economy benefit and 2.3 per cent speed benefit. These are different quantities within one analysis, not contradictory measurements.
In Beaumont and colleagues’ calculation of line positions, another situation produced a 63.3 per cent drag reduction, an estimated 4.4 per cent economy benefit and a possible 2.9 per cent speed benefit. CFD provided force, while metabolic and race-performance conclusions involved further estimation steps. The same runner was not sent through a full marathon in every situation to measure those benefits directly.
The two papers’ figures cannot be arranged into one shared conversion table. Geometry and energetic relationships differ, so a larger force-reduction percentage does not require a larger final economy estimate than another study. Our earlier hundred-unit example illustrates the importance of the component share, but does not reconstruct either study’s complete model precisely.
Force, mechanical power and metabolism are three steps
For straight, steady progress, ground-relative mechanical power associated with overcoming resistance is opposing force multiplied by forward speed. Our example’s ten newtons at five metres per second gives fifty watts; three newtons gives fifteen. The difference is thirty-five watts of external mechanical power. This follows from the given forces and speed, not from a running watch or respiratory test.
We cannot simply rewrite thirty-five watts as the same number of saved metabolic watts. Muscle activity, movement tasks and overcoming an external horizontal force require a separate approach. If a model uses efficiency or an empirical relationship, that choice shapes the result. One general machine efficiency cannot be applied to all human running and used to scale every component of work.
Jenny and Jenny’s 2020 analytical model illustrates this complexity. It connects the mechanical power of level running with factors including speed, step frequency, contact time, body mass and aerodynamic drag. It describes movement under defined assumptions; aerodynamics is part of a larger mechanical system. The model’s structure helps explain variables, but does not automatically replace individual metabolic measurement.
Why does air matter more as speed rises?
In the NASA drag equation, force is proportional to relative airspeed squared if density, frontal area and drag coefficient are held constant. In still air with a fixed body model, relative airspeed equals forward speed. Multiplying by ground-relative speed then makes external aerodynamic power vary with speed cubed under this simplification.
In our numerical example, a body’s drag is three newtons at three metres per second. With the same coefficient, at six metres per second it would be twelve newtons: four times the force. Aerodynamic mechanical power would rise from nine watts to seventy-two, eightfold. This does not mean total human energy expenditure also rises eightfold, because its other components behave differently.
In wind, keep the two speeds separate. Force depends on the body’s speed relative to air; the ground-based mechanical-power calculation also includes forward speed. Someone running at five metres per second into a three-metre-per-second headwind is not travelling at eight metres per second along the course. Do not calculate all power unthinkingly from relative airspeed cubed.
An economy benefit is not the same percentage speed benefit
Lower cost at the same pace and a higher pace at the same cost are different comparisons. The first fixes speed and changes cost. The second fixes a cost budget and asks which new speed fits it. This requires knowing or assuming how total cost changes with speed. One measurement point does not draw the entire curve.
In our deliberately simple artificial example, cost is exactly proportional to speed at every point examined. If the new situation costs 97 per cent of the old at the same pace, a constant budget could allow speed to rise by a factor of 1/0.97, approximately 3.09 per cent. That result follows from our chosen linear relationship. Neither the real total relationship nor the sustainably available budget follows from this exercise.
Speed and finishing time also have a reciprocal relationship over the same distance. If a hypothetical speed increases by three per cent, time does not fall by exactly three per cent: it becomes 1/1.03 of the former time. An original starting example of 240 minutes would become 233.01 minutes purely mathematically. This does not promise anyone a seven-minute improvement; it shows which operation produces each percentage.
Enlarge imageOften only part of the route is sheltered
In most realistic situations, shelter is not constant over the whole distance. Groups split, the road changes direction, the field thins or a runner leaves their pacers. A benefit calculated at one favourable point is not a race-wide average saving. That would require durations and conditions of sheltered and unsheltered sections.
In our numerical example, shelter reduces total cost by four per cent at the same speed, and we spend half the time in it. If everything stays unchanged in the other half, energy over the whole period is two per cent lower. Halving is this simple because we assumed the same baseline power and equal durations. Sections with different speeds or markedly different conditions would need separate weighting.
Transition costs and changes in movement add questions. If maintaining a favourable place requires repeated acceleration, more than the aerodynamic component changes. Applying a modelled benefit preserves it only if other tasks are considered too. A saving is not automatically money kept in a pocket: the entire task may change meanwhile.
How should you read a large aerodynamic promise?
First identify quantity and denominator: drag force, external mechanical power, total metabolic cost or time? Then find speed, wind direction, control and body model. Finally, identify which result was directly measured or calculated and which was derived through further equations. A sound claim provides a traceable chain, not just one large percentage.
Direct human studies have conditions too. In Yamashita and colleagues’ 2024 wind-tunnel research, airflow direction, several airspeeds and the confounding effect of rising temperature were controlled in fourteen participants. The work also shows that air’s metabolic and thermoregulatory roles connect. A drag reduction therefore cannot predict the whole running experience while ignoring the environment.
Seventy per cent can thus be an accurate and important result when its meaning is named. The total energy benefit may be a few per cent because a smaller component is reduced, followed by several separate relationships leading to metabolism and pace. For runners, the value is not the largest figure but a clear, checkable estimation chain: force, mechanical task, total cost and finally the specific application.
Sources
- Schickhofer and Hanson: formation drag and estimated performance benefits.
- Beaumont and colleagues: CFD and energetic model of line positions.
- Jenny and Jenny: mechanical-power model of level running.
- NASA: the drag equation.
- Yamashita and colleagues: airspeed, metabolism and thermoregulation.
How Futószív articles are prepared: our editorial guidelines.


