Your health comes first. This educational article provides general information. Discuss your individual circumstances, pregnancy, illness or symptoms with your clinician; the article cannot replace an individual assessment.

Two runners perform similarly well in shorter assessments, yet convert different proportions of that ability into marathon speed. Percentage of critical speed can help compare performances, but can mislead without the duration of exertion, the estimate’s quality and your own race history. Let us examine the calculation precisely, then the questions it can help answer.

First clarify which speed you are dividing by which

Critical speed, or CS, is a speed parameter derived from a performance–duration relationship. It can be estimated from several sufficiently strong performances of different lengths. Marathon average speed, by contrast, is the total distance of a particular multihour race divided by its time. Comparing them connects two tasks on different scales: a model parameter and the final average of a long event. The percentage summarises that relationship without explaining all its causes.

Relative marathon speed is calculated by dividing marathon speed by CS and multiplying by one hundred. Both speeds must use the same units, such as km/h or m/s. Pace is their inverse: the time needed to cover one kilometre. If dividing min/km values, reverse the order. Many misunderstandings begin when someone treats the larger number of a slower pace as a higher speed.

Suppose your CS corresponds to 4:00 min/km and your marathon average is 4:40 min/km. Converted to seconds, these are 240 and 280. The speed ratio is 240/280, approximately 85.7%. Using speeds gives the same result: 15 km/h and about 12.86 km/h. The reversed ratio, 280/240, does not mean a marathon intensity of 116.7%; it is an incorrectly arranged comparison. The first useful step is therefore checking the calculation and denominator, rather than choosing a percentage.

The same distance takes very different amounts of time

A marathon is a 42.195-kilometre task for every finisher, but not exertion of equal duration. Between three and five hours lie two additional hours of movement, fuelling, heat dissipation and attentional work. One speed parameter describing a fresh condition cannot automatically offset this difference. Two runners moving similarly relative to a shorter performance may still face different situations in the race’s final third.

In the research analysing recreational marathon runners’ raw training data, the ratio of marathon speed to CS was associated with finishing time. Faster groups generally completed the race at a higher relative speed. This is a group-level observation: it does not establish that elapsed time alone causes the difference. Fitness, history, pacing and the response to prolonged exertion may also relate to the pattern.

Copying a fast runner’s percentage and applying the same proportion to a much longer finishing time is therefore misleading. For one person, that number may accompany a marathon history with a stable second half. For another, it would merely conceal a wish. Relative intensity informs when placed alongside duration and training history, rather than replacing them.

Two calculations, two different stories

Imagine two fictional runners. Anna completed a three-hour marathon, so her average speed was 42.195/3, or 14.065 km/h. Her reliably estimated CS is 16 km/h. Marathon speed was approximately 87.9% of that. Béla finished in five hours: his average speed was 8.439 km/h and CS 10.5 km/h. His ratio was about 80.4%. The examples demonstrate the formula, not recommended percentages for three- or five-hour runners.

If Béla mechanically chose Anna’s 87.9%, he would obtain an average around 9.23 km/h, corresponding to roughly a 4-hour-34-minute marathon. This would mean an improvement exceeding twenty-five minutes. Adopting the percentage does not create the necessary training history, tolerance of exertion or fuelling practice. The formula can be mathematically flawless while its practical conclusion lacks foundation.

The opposite inference is inappropriate too: Anna’s higher ratio does not prove that she tolerates pain better, is more thoughtful or is a more valuable runner. Both the CS estimate and marathon result contribute to the ratio. If either input is inaccurate, the comparison changes. In conversation with a running companion, follow the percentage immediately with: when, from which data and under what race conditions was this number produced?

A runner completes a controlled effort on a track while a coach observes the agreed race-pace practice.Enlarge image
AI-generated editorial illustration of targeted race-pace practice; not a documentary photograph or performance prediction.

Uncertainty in the denominator shifts the ratio too

Keep the marathon average at 12.86 km/h. If estimated CS is 15 km/h, the ratio is 85.7%. If another selection of data describes the same runner with a CS of 14.5 km/h, the ratio becomes approximately 88.7%. The marathon itself has not changed; only the reference has. It is easy to misattribute a difference of this size to better endurance or more skilful pacing.

Training files used to determine CS need performances that meaningfully inform the runner’s ability. A value derived from a period containing only easy jogging does not carry the same confidence as an estimate from several appropriate, checked tasks. An erroneous GPS jump may bias it in the other direction. Quality checking means examining whether data actually describe the run from which we want to draw conclusions, rather than choosing the more optimistic result.

Timing correspondence matters too. Dividing last autumn’s race by this spring’s CS may produce an interesting number, but does not measure the same thing as comparing a pre-race preparation window with the following marathon. Keep both dates together in the diary. If you improved or had a long break, do not compress different conditions into one common percentage.

The cost of speed changes during prolonged exertion

The same pace may feel orderly when fresh and demand more effort later. Marathon performance therefore depends not only on starting ability, but also on how usable that ability remains during the race. The concept of durability helps name this time dimension. It is not another score offering a solution to everything, but recognition that a relationship measured at the start of training need not stay constant.

The analysis of data from 82,303 recreational marathon runners examined decoupling of internal and external workload. The relationship between internal response described by heart rate and speed relative to CS varied substantially between individuals. The group showing less decoupling ran faster relative to CS on average and finished with better marathon times. This supports treating changes during the race as important information alongside the speed available at the start.

This does not mean that every rise in heart rate identifies a single shortcoming. Temperature, hydration status, terrain, stops, sensor error and pace changes can all shape the curve. If examining heart rate in relation to pace, first add the conditions. A windy, hot, hilly run cannot be treated as a durability assessment with the same confidence as a repeatable route completed under similar conditions.

Your own marathon pattern belongs beside the percentage

The best comparison often comes from your own similar races. Examine which training produced CS before each marathon, how long the race lasted and how the second half developed. Separately mark heat, substantial elevation changes, illness, technical problems and deliberately slower sections. The ratio then becomes part of an interpretable account rather than floating alone.

A few consistent diary fields suffice: estimate date and data source; CS with units; marathon average speed; calculated ratio; finishing time; and a short description of pacing and conditions. No colourful rating is necessary. Stating that sensor error prevents comparing a result with the others is also a valuable entry.

The study examining physiological and training characteristics of recreational marathon runners shows the combined role of several abilities and training characteristics. Its practical lesson here is not another target value, but interpretation from several perspectives. Place consistency, longer-run experience and the particular race’s demands beside the CS ratio. One good data point does not replace reviewing the entire preparation.

How can data become a decision you can try?

As the next marathon approaches, start with previous stable performance and current preparation. Then use the ratio to CS as a cross-check. If the intended pace represents a substantially higher percentage than your previous ratio, ask which specific new evidence supports it. Has shorter-distance performance improved? Are longer runs going better? Is the expected finishing time different? Or did the calculator merely display an attractive result?

This check does not require running a full marathon at the chosen percentage during preparation. Already planned, purposeful workouts can provide information: rhythm in a later controlled section, whether fuelling works, how the finish feels and the following day. Interpret these observations alongside total weekly load. An exhausting trial added for proof can easily alter the preparation itself.

Between two possible goals, the lower or higher percentage is not necessarily the right deciding criterion. One may have appropriate long-distance history behind it, while another has only a short, fresh performance. A new course or the weather may make neither previous ratio a good reference. Look for the reason behind the difference and note a circumstance that would prompt modifying the race-day plan.

A woman runner reviews her notebook beside a café window, looking for patterns in her running diary.Enlarge image
AI-generated editorial illustration of reviewing a running diary; not a documentary photograph.

Do not defend a ratio during the race

Pre-race percentage of CS is a planning tool, not a contract to fulfil at kilometre thirty regardless of conditions. If holding the displayed pace takes increasingly large and unusual effort, the ratio does not explain the situation. Race decisions also involve the course, heat, fuelling, attention and bodily signals.

Distinguish planned adaptation from faulty data in advance. Slowing on a long climb is not failure in itself; an extreme pace after a GPS dropout is not sudden physiological change. Trying to restore the displayed percentage at all costs can answer a measurement or environmental problem inappropriately. Your own rhythm and verifiable splits may help more then.

Unusual chest symptoms, near-fainting or confusion are a different category from normal race fatigue: stopping and obtaining on-site help take priority over the performance plan. This is mentioned not because CS calculations are especially dangerous, but because no technical metric can decide whether illness is acceptable. The number serves to describe running, not override symptoms.

The most useful comparison is personal and ordered in time

Marathon speed relative to CS becomes a good question when it moves away from ranking running companions. For example: why is my own ratio lower now although shorter results improved? Why did I pace more evenly with a similar ratio? How much does replacing uncertain CS with a better-supported estimate change the picture? Diaries, conditions and data from several dates can help answer.

For the next analysis, make a short three-part note. First record the formula and checked inputs. Second summarise race duration and progression. Third identify one decision you genuinely reconsider because of the data. If there is none, the percentage can remain interesting background information; it need not automatically acquire a new workout or stricter goal.

Different runners’ different percentages then become an understandable consequence of the marathon’s multihour, individual demands rather than an awkward exception. Relative speed shows a relationship between shorter performance and a long race. Good preparation decisions additionally require knowing how reliable both ends of the relationship are, how long it needed to hold and how your running developed along the way.

Sources

Helpful? Pass it on.